Sustainability Supplement

Are universities living up to their climate commitments?

The cafeteria could be undercutting universities’ pledges to environmental sustainability.

By Julie Hoeflinger

17 November 2026

In brief

  • Universities target ambitious carbon neutrality, yet many overlook the heavy environmental footprint of campus food catering.
  • Research reveals campus menus severely exceed recommended targets, while transparent reporting on food procurement remains rare.
  • Institutions must slash high-emission foods, expand plant-based options and provide transparent data to fulfil climate pledges.

How seriously can a university take its sustainability promises if it’s overlooking the environmental impact of its food? Countless universities have announced sweeping climate action plans in the past decade, many with goals to become carbon neutral by 2025 and 2030. But can a university truly be a climate leader if it fails to measure, report and reduce food-related greenhouse gas emissions?

The carbon expense hidden in plain sight

Our food systems — most notably, animal agriculture — have an enormous carbon footprint and are extremely water-intensive. Food contributes to nearly one-third of global greenhouse gas emissions, and around 25 percent of global methane emissions are caused by meat and livestock production, yet it’s often left out of the climate conversation.

The data is not lacking: roughly 30 percent of all global freshwater goes to animal production, most of which is used for growing livestock feed. Beef production places a disproportionately high demand on water resources, requiring 1,800 gallons of water to produce a single pound of boneless beef.

Dr Isaac Emery, a sustainability scientist who studies life cycle environmental impacts, explains why animal agriculture has such a heavy environmental impact. “A very large amount of the land area for farming that we have in the US, we use to feed cows, pigs and chickens instead of just feeding ourselves,” he says.

“So that's all land that we're fertilising that we could be feeding other people with instead of other animals.”

Over 75 percent of all agricultural land is used for livestock and to grow feed for livestock. Dr Emery emphasises that current levels of meat consumption place unsustainable demands on finite resources.

“I am never going to be somebody to tell people not to eat any beef, I’m not going to try and take that away from people,” he adds.

“I do think that as a society we need to be shifting from lots of meat to less meat because there simply isn't enough land and water on Earth for us all to eat kind of as luxuriously as we'd like.”

Universities are leaders in environmental research, and climate action commitments have become widespread across higher education. But these commitments raise questions about whether institutions are doing enough to address emissions associated with the food they purchase and serve.

The accountability gap

Research suggests a substantial disconnect between universities’ sustainability commitments and their food procurement practices. A study conducted in 2022 examined 19 US university dining programmes. Researchers compared the universities’ catering service carbon emissions against targets provided by the EAT-Lancet planetary health diet, an international framework designed to improve human health and reduce our agricultural carbon emissions. They found that the participating institutions’ menus exceeded recommended targets considerably: beef was 657 percent above target, pork 587 percent and poultry 379 percent, while legumes, nuts and vegetables were all well below recommended targets.

Some universities, such as the University of Washington, focus their food-related goals on increasing the percentage of local food sourcing rather than explicitly targeting emissions from high-impact food categories. Other institutions, such as Rutgers, have measured the high emissions of their beef and chicken purchasing alongside goals of reducing these meats by 25 percent by 2030. However, publicly accessible information demonstrating progress towards such targets can be difficult to locate.

While several institutions have measured their catering-related carbon footprints and implemented sustainability policies, questions remain about how consistently progress is reported. Have universities with targets to reduce meat purchasing successfully done so? For those with timelines to achieve certain benchmarks by 2030, are they on track to reach those targets?

The University of Maryland, College Park announced a commitment to achieve carbon neutrality by 2025 and has documented its progress through an updated Climate Action Plan. Its plan includes a commitment to reduce greenhouse gas emissions associated with food procurement by 25 percent by 2030. The university also provides comprehensive emissions data, including findings showing that beef has the highest environmental impact on its menu, comprising 50 percent of all food-related emissions annually despite accounting for only 3.6 percent of its food purchases. Its website reported a 33.1 percent reduction in greenhouse gas emissions per plate compared with 2015, but it’s not clear whether beef purchasing has been addressed in recent years.

The University of Idaho also promises carbon neutrality, with plans to reach it by 2030. In a report from 2020, the university identified animals and fertiliser as among the top five largest emissions sources on campus. The university also measured food-related emissions by category and found that its emissions have increased in recent years, partly due to the increasing number of cows on campus. Yet in its 2026-2031 Sustainable Solutions Report, its strategy emphasises reducing waste as a means to make food systems more sustainable, adding that animal agriculture is offset by other sustainability practices.

Ohio State University is one of the largest universities in the United States, giving it considerable influence through its operations and purchasing decisions. In its 2011 Climate Action Plan, the university announced its commitment to cut carbon emissions to zero by 2050 along with a 55 percent benchmark by 2030. But publicly available information on progress in reducing food-related emissions is less readily accessible.

While the university reported that it has reduced greenhouse gas emissions 30 percent since 2015, there was a near-zero percent change in emissions from 2022. Still, two years ago, Executive Vice President and Provost Bruce A. McPheron wrote:

"By reducing our carbon emissions, the university is doing its part to minimise the negative impacts that climate change will present over time.”

At the end of last year, the university published recommendations on eating less red meat and more plant-based foods, but it was difficult to locate a public report demonstrating the university’s plan to reduce beef or other high-carbon foods on its own menus. This highlights a clear discrepancy in what institutions claim to value and what their policies actually reflect, which is certainly not unique to any one institution.

Nine universities contacted for this story have not responded to requests for comment.

To be clear, a lack of publicly available information does not necessarily equate to a lack of action, but for large, wealthy institutions with tremendous research capabilities and major climate commitments, greater transparency about their food-related emissions and progress towards reduction targets is a reasonable expectation.

It’s also important to note that at every university, there are dedicated individuals and teams working tirelessly to address the climate crisis and improve sustainable practices, but they may not have the power to implement more drastic campus-wide changes.

This conversation also raises a broader question about exactly what being “carbon-neutral” entails. A university can achieve carbon neutrality by purchasing carbon offsets from off-site organisations to compensate for its carbon emissions; for example, paying a wind farm to generate renewable energy. This reality has led many climate experts to scrutinise the legitimacy of the term because while credible offsets can play a role in climate strategies, reliance on them may also reduce the incentive to make more substantial operational changes.

Leaders in sustainable food systems

Some higher education institutions have made significant progress in addressing their food-related emissions. The University of Cambridge completely removed beef from its university catering service menus in 2016, dramatically reducing its environmental footprint in the years since. Goldsmiths, University of London and the University of Coimbra in Portugal followed suit in 2019 to meet their own climate action goals.

Imperial College London removed beef from its menus in 2024 ahead of its 2026 timeline and shared why the decision was made along with how students reacted.

“Beef came out as by far the biggest carbon footprint element in the catering supply chain,” explains Harriet Wallace, the Director of Sustainability Strategy at Imperial. “And so that's led to [the decision to] stop serving beef and transition to a wider range of things.”

Although the decision initially faced some resistance, the response has since changed.

“It was initially quite controversial, but honestly, the comments did die down quite quickly. There was a little bit of resistance to change, but we weren't planning on backtracking at all,” shares Ella Shepherd, the Catering Operations Manager and Sustainability Lead for Hospitality. “Two years on, we get zero comments about it now. New people that come in, new students, zero comments. So, it's just a new norm now.”

Their Sustainable Food and Drink Policy for 2026-2031 plans to increase plant-based food options to 40 percent by 2031 alongside a number of other targets such as reducing plastic takeaway containers by 75 percent and introducing plastic-free packaging made from seaweed extracts.

“We're a science-based education institution, and so we are a place that is through and through evidence-based, and we want to be a leader on these things,” Wallace emphasises.

“And so that process of taking people through these things and helping them understand what we're doing and why is all part of being an education institution. If we can't be a bit front-footed on this, I don't know who can, when the evidence is so clear.”

In the United States, perhaps the most impressive sustainable food procurement achievement made by a higher education institution was the University of Colorado Boulder ranking first on the Humane Society Scorecard last year after its menu became 75 percent plant-based.

The Humane Society of the United States creates a scorecard each year assessing higher education institutions’ sustainable food practices, specifically how well they have shifted from reliance on animal products to introducing more plant-forward options.

The Humane Society International also works with institutions to increase plant-based menus, offering a diversity of options. Kymberly Bower is a Food Service Innovation Specialist for the organisation, and her work involves collaborating with large-scale food service operators to increase their sustainable plant-based menu offerings and reduce reliance on animal products through practical, achievable and innovative strategies, all at zero cost to the institution.

“We help with menu and recipe development and product procurement, and we help increase [plant-based] options,” Bower says. “And not only increase the options but make sure that they are delicious.”

Bower emphasises that higher education institutions can exert considerable influence through their catering decisions, particularly as students show growing interest in sustainability.

“With universities in particular, I think we have a really unique opportunity just because of today's generation of students being extremely interested in sustainability, [which] greatly ties into plant-based foods,” Bower says.

“And not only are today's students interested in sustainability but also so interested in health and the ethical concerns of our food system, so it really positions universities as great partners for us.”

Higher education climate commitments should face public scrutiny

As universities work towards their climate targets, food procurement deserves greater attention alongside other sources of emissions. Institutional purchasing decisions hold immense power to influence food systems, and several universities have shown that more ambitious strategies are possible and can deliver measurable reductions in environmental impact.

With scientists urging that rapid decarbonisation is needed to slow the worst of the climate crisis, we need bolder strategies. If there are limitations to what a university can achieve in terms of sustainable practice, they should be expected to be transparent about what they are doing, what they aren’t doing, and why. Students, faculty, and the public have every right to ask universities to make their climate commitments count.

MEET THE AUTHOR


Julie Hoeflinger is a freelance journalist currently based in her hometown of Toledo, Ohio. She covers science, higher education, social justice, and local news. With a bachelor’s degree in neuroscience and a master’s degree in science communications from Imperial College London, her work is as gripping as it is accurate. Her work has been featured in QS Insights, New Scientist, Toledo Parent, ZME Science, Action for Conservation, I,Science Magazine, and Imperial College Radio.