Sustainability Supplement
Can we, and do we, really want it all?
As more women pursue higher education and professional careers, falling fertility raises hard questions about academic ambition, support and motherhood.
By Prisha Dandwani


Sustainability Supplement
Can we, and do we, really want it all?
As more women pursue higher education and professional careers, falling fertility raises hard questions about academic ambition, support and motherhood.
By Prisha Dandwani
17 November 2026
In brief
- Global fertility continues dropping despite government bonuses, as educated women face deep structural and workplace barriers.
- Precarity and intense tenure demands penalise academic motherhood, pushing female scholars to delay childbirth or work through leave.
- Institutions must reform career structures, recognise caregiving in performance reviews and offer genuine work-life flexibility for parents.
In 1970, the average woman had 4.8 children. By 2024, according to a United Nation’s World Fertility Report, she had 2.2. In South Korea, the decline has been steeper still – about 70% since 1980. Policymakers fear that an ageing, lopsided population will weaken innovation and the economy.
In response, governments are reaching for their chequebooks. In East Asia, Hong Kong’s 2026 Policy Address offers HK$30,000 for a second and subsequent child, alongside tax and housing incentives, while Singapore’s Baby Bonus scheme offers cash payments to new parents.
But financial incentives alone are unlikely to persuade women to have children. Even for a female graduate who wants children and has settled into a stable job, cleared student loans, and found the right partner, baby bonuses barely cover rising living and childcare costs.
The relationship between education and fertility also varies considerably across countries. An OECD study found that in Japan, South Korea, Hong Kong and Taiwan, women with higher education are more likely to remain childless than less educated women. This reflects, in part, the difficulties of combining employment and motherhood.
In Denmark, Norway and Sweden, stronger childcare provision and work-life balance policies mean highly educated women can have fertility rates equal to or higher than those of less educated women.
The bill of motherhood
Dr Jennifer Glass, Professor Emeritus of work and family issues and gender stratification at the University of Texas at Austin, says she is not surprised by the fertility decline in East Asia, having heard and seen the pressures women face at home and at work.
“I heard these women in South Korea, for example, who said they feel the men are awful, the jobs are awful, and the only way they can see themselves having any life and not being a servant to anyone else is to avoid having kids,” she recalls.
She points to laws that encourage discriminatory attitudes against “illegitimate children”, and to the expectations that women should shoulder responsibilities for both immediate and extended family. These, she argues, are serious structural disincentives to childbearing.
More importantly, she places declining fertility within a historical economic transformation.
“For 150 years, we have been watching industrialisation capture nation state after another and as it does, fertility falls. We raise children for future employers.”
For Dr Glass, the solutions currently offered by government are ineffective. She points out that women now shoulder financial responsibilities in addition to bearing and feeding children. More than half of American mothers are the family breadwinner responsible for more than 60% of household earnings.
“It used to be that the resources you give to your children were created by the family unit, like husbands, mothers-in-law, fathers-in-law and grandparents. But now, those actors are pulling back.
“There’s also been this ludicrous idea that women could stop their education and have children first when they are young. There is plenty of research to show that bad things follow that. That’s what can contribute to poverty. You see bad grades. Delinquency,” Dr Glass says.
“We have known for a long time that marrying young and having poor financial skills are the strongest indicators of divorce and family dissolution.”
She acknowledges that higher education plays a significant role. Higher education leaders, she says, should keep offering flexibility to student parents, build on-site childcare and explore more financial aid. The key is to keep parents in school.
Just as important, she argues, is how the labour market operates: how employers treat their employees and what the working week looks like. Universities can play an instrumental role here through career coaching for students and guiding them on how to find a good employer.
“If companies start hearing these real questions from graduates, they will eventually learn it is something they must address,” she says.
The academic treadmill
Karen Jones, Professor of Educational Leadership and Management at the University of Reading in the UK, has researched how women’s reproductive decisions are shaped. Like Dr Glass, she does not believe that one-off financial incentives will substantially affect women’s decisions while deeper structural challenges remain unaddressed.
“In my research on women’s experiences of maternity leave in universities, participants often described feeling that motherhood was incompatible with the image of the ideal academic worker who is continuously productive, constantly available and wholly committed to work,” Professor Jones explains.
A striking finding from her research is that many women kept working while officially on maternity leave: participants reported checking emails, answering student queries, maintaining research projects and preparing grant applications. Many fear that career interruptions are still read as a sign of reduced competitiveness.
This environment, Professor Jones says, leads women to delay having children, have fewer children or remain childless altogether. “Women often return from maternity leave to find their publication records, grant applications and professional networks have been disrupted.”
She identifies two pressures. The first is precarity: early-career academics increasingly work on fixed-term or project-funded contracts, and many delay motherhood for want of the security of a permanent post.
The second is timing. The most uncertain stages of an academic career, from doctoral study to postdoctoral posts to tenure, often coincide with women’s prime reproductive years, precisely when academics are expected to demonstrate maximum productivity and establish reputations.
Her advice to university leaders: count career breaks and caregiving in promotion and performance reviews, ease early-career insecurity, support women returning from leave and encourage shared caregiving.
The brighter side
For some, motherhood and the tenacity it fosters can actually enhance careers. Jenny Donnelly, Vice President of Engineering at Fluency Inc and Principal at Granite Technology Advisory, has been a leader in software engineering for over 15 years. She had her first child while working as a manager at Yahoo.
Though initially, balancing motherhood and leadership responsibilities left her overwhelmed, Donnelly tells QS Insights it was a golden opportunity to reevaluate how she organised her time.
“It felt like burning a candle at both ends. I felt like I didn’t know how to keep this up. I eventually hit rock bottom and had to clear the slate. I used to think I needed to do everything perfectly. Whether it was fixing every [technical] bug on the list or answering every email alongside domestic tasks — the pressure was on.”
She recalls a moment of “fortuitous timing” when she came across a book called Mindset by Carol Dweck. It helped her reevaluate how she framed her experiences and how to be more productive and discerning with her time.
“For instance, I was able to do manager training and apply that to being a parent — a lot of those skills are transferable. I thought about how I could rebuild my workday in this new world of constraints. I focussed on what my manager cared about and getting that done first,” Donnelly says.
Her success was not without support— she emphasises long-term help.
“We decided to outsource some of the domestic help. At first, I felt like it was not worth it in terms of the budget, and it also kind of felt like failing. But as soon as I changed my framing, it meant that every minute of me not doing XYZ gave me time to reinvest in other things that were the best use of my time.
“I think governments and leaders need to think about it holistically. Greater systemic support for women would help them thrive in their careers. Being present for the things that matter and delegating for the things that don’t is such a privilege. If we could try and afford that privilege to every mother, what a different world this would be,” she says.
Donnelly is careful not to present her experience as a universal solution. Every woman's circumstances, ambitions and decisions about parenthood are different. Making the decision with eyes wide open and being cognisant of one’s own agency is key, she says.
The power of choice
The fertility debate goes beyond how governments can persuade women to have more children – women need to feel ready and supported if they want to have children at all.
Financial incentives may ease some immediate expenses, but they cannot compensate for insecure employment, inflexible workplaces or unequal caregiving responsibilities. Nor should the responsibility for reversing demographic decline rest primarily with women.
For universities, the implications are twofold. As educators, they can support student parents and prepare graduates to navigate workplace expectations. As employers, they must also examine whether their own career structures penalise those who take time away for caregiving.
One of the biggest rewards for those who raise children is eventually watching them become robust, healthy and kind people who contribute to society. As Dr Glass tells QS Insights: “You can make women have more children, but you can’t ensure they are raised well.”
We all have a stake in that.
MEET THE AUTHOR
Prisha Dandwani contributes to QS as a communications and research specialist with over 10 years experience working with companies in Hong Kong and London. As a previous contract Deputy Editor at QS, she feels strongly about developments in the higher education sector that indicate how academic priorities and incoming graduates can shape the global landscape in the years to come.

