Features

The price of speaking out

Are sponsorship deals silencing student-athletes?

As sportswear brands sign athletes at increasingly younger ages, an offensive sneaker advertisement raises questions about the cost of speaking out and the influence of corporate sponsorships.

By Jamaal Abdul-Alim

Features

The price of speaking out

Are sponsorship deals silencing student-athletes?

As sportswear brands sign athletes at increasingly younger ages, an offensice sneaker advertisement raises questions about the cost of speaking out and the influence of corporate sponsorships.

By Jamaal Abdul-Alim

17 November 2026

In brief

  • Lucrative sponsorships silence young student-athletes, preventing them from calling out corporate misconduct and racism.
  • Fear of lost endorsements and career blacklisting discourages college stars from risking their financial futures.
  • Early commercialisation risks erasing student activism, forcing athletes to choose between financial security and principles.

When Converse — the Boston-based footwear company behind the iconic Chuck Taylor All-Star sneaker — released an ad in September 2026 that evoked images of the Ku Klux Klan and lynching, it deservedly drew widespread rebuke and disbelief.

Civil rights attorney Lee Merritt, who represented the family of Ahmaud Arbery, a Black man shot to death in a hate crime in 2020 while jogging in a predominantly white neighbourhood in Georgia, said the company's apology could not explain how such an offensive advertisement ever got cleared.

“This wasn’t hidden. It was styled, lit and approved by a creative team,” Merritt said. “Converse says sorry…. An apology doesn’t undo what got past legal, marketing and leadership at every step.”

Merritt and others, such as journalist Don Lemon, said the case underscores the importance of diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives within corporations.

“Take diversity seriously, and maybe you wouldn’t end up with something that looks like a damn KKK lynching,” Lemon said.

“We keep having this conversation because corporations keep failing the same test,” Merritt added.

As disturbing as this marketing failure may have been, the debacle has brought to light a potentially more disturbing issue, which has implications for college athletes of today and the ones coming up behind them.

This failure is the apparent silence of athletes towards the ad. Despite searching for public responses from athletes at the collegiate and professional levels, I routinely came up empty-handed.

What’s the reason behind the silence? Are Black athletes giving sneaker companies a pass on racism because they don’t want to bite the hand that feeds them?

And if so, what kind of example does this set for current high school and college athletes as they seek to navigate their athletic careers and score endorsement deals of their own?

The growing influence of sponsorships

Sportswear and sneaker companies are engaging with student-athletes at a younger and younger age. For instance, Adidas signed 15-year-old RJ Evans and, two years earlier, at the age of 16, Kaleena Smith, whom the company hailed as “the future of women’s basketball”.

Nike recently signed 11 top high school football prospects to what the company says is its “growing” roster of high school athletes.

French soccer phenom Kylian Mbappé recently ended a 20-year partnership with Nike that began when he was just eight.

Sneaker companies are signing these young athletes at a time when they’re supposed to be learning to question the world. While these arrangements provide significant financial opportunities, they also introduce young athletes to the commercial expectations of the sports industry while they are still developing their identities.

One of my colleagues at the University of Maryland, where this past spring I pioneered and developed a sneaker journalism course, gave a stark assessment.

“Athletes get inculcated at such a young age, their ability to critique has all but been lobotomised by the time they reach adulthood,” said Kevin Blackistone, a professor of the practice at Maryland’s Philip Merrill College of Journalism, where this semester he is teaching a course called “Sports, Protest and the Media”.

Professor Blackistone told me this was a concern he had held “for a long time”.

The athletes I spoke with had a slightly different take — but similarly disquieting one nonetheless.

“A lot of athletes are scared,” a Division I athlete at a Jordan Brand-sponsored university told me during a discussion with a group of high schoolers about the apparent lack of athlete responses against the Converse ad.

The student spoke on the condition of anonymity in order to speak freely without fear of institutional or social reprisals.

They explained that college athletes saw how Colin Kaepernick got blacklisted by the NFL for protesting racial injustice, or how a Fox News commentator told LeBron James to “shut up and dribble” for speaking about politics, and concluded that speaking up is not worth the trouble if it means losing out on endorsement deals.

That math didn’t sit well with “Tom-Tom,” an elder from the community near the university where the student is an athlete.

“We’ll take two steps forward, and go 200 years back,” Tom-Tom said of student-athletes being reluctant to criticise sneaker companies for fear of losing out on sneaker deals.

The cost of taking a stand

The financial consequences of challenging a sponsor are not merely hypothetical. I put the question to Allyson Felix, one of the most decorated track-and-field Olympians in US history. Felix challenged Nike over maternity protections and fought for fairer financial terms in sponsorship contracts for women athletes, an experience explored in her documentary film, “She Runs the World”.

Felix said in the documentary that speaking out once she became a mother was one of the hardest things she’s ever done.

When Felix visited Howard University for a screening of the documentary, I stepped to the microphone during the Q&A in Cramton Auditorium and asked her about the seeming silence among athletes towards the Converse advertisement and what advice she would offer student-athletes who are trying to balance their principles against the prospect of losing sponsorships.

Her response highlighted the financial pressures that can influence an athlete's decision to speak publicly.

“I think for a lot of athletes, they build a lot of pressure from a lot of different places. I think the first place that they go to is financially. You know, whatever the responsibilities are, there are real consequences of speaking out.”

Felix recalled the personal cost of her dispute with Nike. “In my situation, I didn't get paid for two years, and I think with your, whatever your situation is, I think you're always weighing, like, can I, do I have the ability to do this? Like, if worst case scenario, if I lose whatever my sponsorship, will I be okay? What are your responsibilities? Who are you taking care of? I think there's just a real-life thing about it.”

“In the situation in the film, I think there was a point where it was like, okay, I could lose everything. Like, I feel that strongly about it, that I want to keep moving forward,” she added.

“I think it's a deeply personal decision, kind of at every phase, that you have to answer for what you decide to do… I think people do have really strong opinions, but oftentimes, it comes with a lot when you speak [out].”

The responsibility to speak out

It’s not like today’s student-athletes don’t know racism when they see it and rightly call it out. For instance, when the club tennis team at the University of Maryland sent out correspondence this semester that incorporated images of KKK hoods into the Maryland state flag, tennis players at Howard University, who received the correspondence, complained.

The University of Maryland suspended the club tennis team indefinitely. Students at the University of Maryland have since called on the administration to identify the students who sent offensive graphics that featured the KKK hoods.

It’d be more worthwhile, in my opinion, if student-athletes took a similar interest in the calls to unmask the Converse employees behind the Klan-esque sneaker ad.

Is it too much to expect student-athletes to lay down the gauntlet, so to speak, and make a statement to sneaker companies that no amount of money or sneakers or athletic gear is worth the blatant disrespect?

History shows that, indeed – as Felix had indicated – when you speak out, there are consequences. San José State University students Tommie Smith and John Carlos found that out the hard way after they raised their gloved fists in a Black power salute on the podium of the 1968 Olympics in Mexico City to protest racial oppression.

They subsequently faced ostracisation and suffered in their careers. But they also ended up producing one of the most iconic images in sports history — one that routinely finds itself in school textbooks.

Their protest remains a defining moment in the relationship between sport and social justice, even if the photograph is often presented in a decontextualised and oversimplified way. At least everyone who views it knows where Smith and Carlos stood and where this photograph stands in the annals of sports history.

Unfortunately, when it comes to the Converse ad debacle, there won’t be a similar record of athletes – whether at the college or professional level – taking any sort of similar stance.

In fact, it appears as if they took no stance at all.

MEET THE AUTHOR


Jamaal Abdul-Alim is the founding editor of Sneaker Theory, a website meant to promote the study of the global sneaker industry and culture. He is also the creator of JOUR459X, a first-of-its-kind sneaker journalism course pioneered at the University of Maryland at College Park.