Analysis

There’s more to rank than reputation

Japan’s universities have stellar reputations, but declining impact and limited international mobility are putting them under pressure in the rankings.

By Rohan Mehra

Analysis

There’s more to rank than reputation

Japan’s universities have stellar reputations, but declining impact and limited international mobility are putting them under pressure in the rankings.

By Rohan Mehra

17 November 2026

In brief

  • Japanese universities drop in regional rankings despite strong reputations, constrained by declining research impact and limited international mobility.
  • Weak citation scores, entrenched academic self-recruitment practices and uncompetitive contracts prevent international scholars from staying and thriving.
  • Sustaining research performance demands deeper institutional reform, proper funding and genuine integration of foreign talent.

The QS World University Rankings: Asia 2027 are out , with some trends continuing as expected and others coming as a bit of a surprise. Most of the region’s top-performing universities in places such as Hong Kong, Singapore and mainland China maintain their positions or rise slightly. But in Japan, all eight universities in the top 50 have fallen by varying degrees, and no Japanese university is present in Asia’s top 25 anymore.

The results are striking given that Japan’s leading universities continue to perform strongly on several indicators. Scores for academic reputation, employer reputation, international research network and staff with PhDs are close to perfect for some institutions. Where things turn sour, however, are in two key areas that are strongly interconnected: research impact and internationalisation.

Japan's top eight universities average just 26.7 out of 100 for citations per paper, compared with 80.5 for the other universities in Asia's top 50. This has created a dichotomy in which universities with established reputations struggle to keep pace with their regional competitors, and are looking for ways to improve.

What citations measure

Research impact is measured through citation metrics. They are widely used to assess academic influence, but they do not necessarily capture the full picture of a university’s research.

“Citation impact should not be confused with universities’ broader educational, economic and social contributions,” Professor Futao Huang from Hiroshima University’s Research Institute for Higher Education tells QS Insights.

“Japan’s decline in the ranks reflects domestic constraints and faster progress elsewhere in Asia. Strong academic reputations rest on achievements accumulated over decades, while sustaining research performance requires adequate funding, protected research time and opportunities for younger scholars.” Research priorities may also help explain the disparity. As David Pendlebury in 2020 and Alonso Rodríguez-Navarro and Ricardo Brito in 2024 suggest, Japan has advanced research infrastructure, but not all research aims to produce breakthroughs. There is fundamental research, and there’s incremental research; Japan, grounded in its industrial and technology manufacturing sectors, leans on the latter.

“Japan’s research favours established topics,” says Masatsura Igami, Director of the Center for Science & Technology Foresight and Indicators at the National Institute of Science and Technology Policy (NISTEP). “Highly cited papers often reflect novelty, popularity or attention rather than research quality or societal value.

“Limited resources and laboratories more focused on student training may affect citation performance too.”

Lower citation scores do not necessarily indicate weaker research, but they do raise questions about visibility and international reach.

Collaboration without mobility

Pendlebury, Rodríguez-Navarro and Brito also point strongly to the problem with visibility in terms of limited exposure in non-domestic journals, media, conferences and so on. However, Japan's internationalisation problem is not straightforward.

Their strong performance in the international research network indicator demonstrates an ability of Japanese researchers to collaborate across borders. Yet international collaboration has not translated into comparable levels of student and faculty mobility, exchange and integration.

It’s well studied that cross-border research improves measured impact — the title of a 2017 article in Nature by Cassidy R Sugimoto and others sums it up best: “Scientists have most impact when they're free to move”. Though that article examines international mobility through a political lens, the point remains the same: internationalisation drives impact.

Professor Hugo Horta studies higher education policy and research careers at the University of Hong Kong and was previously at Tohoku University in Japan.

“If you want to hear about state-of-the-art knowledge, you need to be tuned in to and integrated with the global discourse,” he tells QS Insights.

“Problems arise when someone closed off from the world tries to submit to international journals. It might backfire; they might tell you, ‘this work is outdated, there's nothing new here’. So, you can't publish or end up publishing in lower-tier journals where they accept stuff that is not that relevant, not that impactful, not that significant.”

Barriers to institutional change

The issue goes beyond whether Japanese researchers collaborate internationally. Another question is whether universities are sufficiently open to the movement of people and ideas.

Professor Horta explores the topic of academic inbreeding: the tendency for universities to recruit and retain their own graduates, including how this affects academic careers and institutional development of Japan’s research sector.

While the practice exists across the world, he believes Japanese universities have been comparatively reluctant to challenge it because academic inbreeding aligns with wider societal and organisational preferences for stability, harmony and institutional continuity.

By its very nature, however, academic inbreeding, especially in a country like Japan, impedes the integration of foreign researchers and the outward mobility of domestic ones.

“Say you complete your PhD in a given university and remain there throughout your career. You have essentially become immobile,” Professor Horta says.

"In Japanese universities, communication and collaboration tend to be internal. You collaborate with other colleagues; many of them are academically inbred as well. And of course, it goes well because you think the same way. There is an interest in maintaining structures and activities without changing them, but the world moves on, and you get left behind.”

Internationalisation has long been on Japan’s higher education agenda. But Professor Horta notes that execution sometimes falls short.

“Some universities send researchers abroad, hoping they’ll return with ideas for reform. But it consistently fails. When they return, these researchers are often scattered across different universities, isolated and without sufficient influence to bring about change,” he says.

“Instead, they find themselves assimilated into existing systems and quickly realise that unless they fall back in line, their careers will go nowhere.”

Attracting talent is only half the challenge

All this goes some way to explaining the low scores for international faculty and students, especially for outbound student exchange. Among Japan’s universities in Asia’s top 50, the average score for outbound student exchange falls to around 50 points out of 100, while the rest in the top 50 average over 95.

But attracting foreign researchers is only part of the challenge. Retaining and integrating them is another matter. Assistant Professor Lilan Chen at Waseda University in Tokyo studies higher education internationalisation, diversity, equity and inclusion – another issue Japanese universities are struggling with.

“I interviewed 40 international academics for my PhD thesis. Most entered Japanese universities because they had some prior connection to Japan through studying, exchange programmes or past employment. Only two had arrived independently,” says Chen.

“But internationalisation isn't just about how many foreigners there are at a university. Beyond just their presence, we need to consider their integration. Do they really feel they are members of the university or department? Beyond policies and institutional initiatives, we need to pay more attention to individuals' experiences and their sense of belonging. It’s essential to achieving more comprehensive internationalisation.”

In a 2022 article, Chen identified obstacles to attracting and retaining good foreign talent, ranging from limited career opportunities to institutional exclusion. These are compounded by salaries that are increasingly uncompetitive internationally.

“Salaries in Japan are relatively low, research grants can be difficult to obtain, and career development is often restricted. Many international academics would happily come for a short-term visit, but relocating permanently is another matter,” she says.

“Many junior faculty are hired on limited contracts with no guarantee of employment afterwards. That uncertainty makes it difficult to commit to Japan long term. Speaking from my own experience, many of my friends and I are already looking at opportunities in other countries. We have spent many years in Japan, but if a good tenure-track position becomes available in Hong Kong, Macau or mainland China, many of us might consider moving.”

Beyond rankings

Japan’s ranking performance has prompted efforts at both governmental and institutional levels to address research and internationalisation concerns. But what researchers seem to agree on is that, while relatively poor impact and internationalisation are significant issues, these are really symptoms of a more fundamental institutional attitude.

“Internationalisation remains partly symbolic when recruitment targets receive more attention than changes to everyday institutional practices,” says Professor Huang.

Nor is internationalisation a solution to every weakness in research performance. NISTEP’s Igami argues that universities must also address the conditions under which research takes place.

“Internationalisation is an important part of the research environment, but it should not be an end in itself. International collaboration expands research networks, diversifies sources of knowledge and connects researchers with emerging research communities and topics,” he says.

“However, improving research impact requires more than internationalisation alone. Sufficient funding, research time, intellectual curiosity and support for younger researchers are equally important.”

Between reports from NISTEP, high-level funding initiatives coupled to institutional reform, as well as other motivations for change, it’s clear that issues relating to declining rankings – and everything that implies – are being noticed and addressed. However, it remains to be seen whether these developments will show up in rankings improvement.

Japan's universities have spent decades building the reputations they enjoy today. But reputation is only a reflection of past achievements, whereas rankings increasingly measure how institutions perform against rapidly advancing competitors. Japan's challenge today is not simply to improve its scores, but to ensure that its research environment can sustain the reputation it has worked so hard to earn.

MEET THE AUTHOR


Rohan is a STEAM communicator based in Tokyo. He works with universities to improve the depth, breadth, quality, and quantity of their public facing communications output. His main focus is on writing, producing short films, and lecturing post-graduates about research communication. Typical of STEAM communicators, he’s worked in a broad range of roles including as a TV producer, animator, researcher, editor, museum curator, public speaker, and journalist. Alongside these things he’s also taught continuously since the mid 2000’s, running workshops for adults, children, and under-represented groups on film production, animation, and more.