Spotlight

Why must we default to dystopia?

The Indigenous right to imagine the future.

By Dr Kiri Dell

Spotlight

Why must we default to dystopia?

The Indigenous right to imagine the future.

By Dr Kiri Dell

17 November 2026

Everywhere we turn, whether TikTok, news feeds or podcasts, some kind of dystopian future is being projected onto us. At the forefront of these catastrophic predictions is AI domination: humanity dependent on systems it can no longer understand or control or worse, wiped out by AI gone rogue. Close behind are prophecies of climate collapse and an uninhabitable planet where ecological systems can no longer support human life. And the doomsday predictions go on: extreme inequality, surveillance societies, the end of privacy, the loss of human purpose and the collapse of human connection.

A warning, not a destiny

Dystopian thinking serves a purpose. It warns us about the consequences of decisions we are making today, and those consequences deserve attention.

Dystopian narratives are compelling because they mobilise fear, and fear can motivate necessary action. But fear may also narrow the range of alternative futures we consider. When the future is presented mainly as a series of threats, our response becomes defensive and reactive. We prepare. We adapt. We try to minimise damage. These are important responses, but they position us as accepting these futures rather than actively creating one. We also risk creating self-fulfilling prophecies.

We must distinguish between imagining dystopia as a warning and accepting it as destiny. If we keep presenting the future as an inevitable slide towards collapse, we shrink our collective imagination and become preoccupied with managing decline rather than creating something desirable. Perhaps one of the greatest challenges facing humanity is not a crisis of sustainability or technology, but a crisis of imagining thriving futures.

An Indigenous mindset brings two perspectives to this challenge.

1. Been there, done that

For many Indigenous Peoples, dystopia is a history we have already lived through. And yet, we are still here. Colonisation brought catastrophic population loss, dispossession, environmental destruction, suppression of languages, disruption of governance systems and the attempted elimination of entire ways of being.

Many of the conditions imagined in dystopian fiction, from loss of autonomy and cultural erasure to surveillance and displacement, are recognisable in Indigenous histories of colonisation. An Indigenous response might therefore focus on how people continue to create meaningful futures under conditions they did not choose.

Despite enormous disruption, Indigenous Peoples continue to maintain knowledge, relationships, cultural practices and collective identities. Languages have been revitalised. Lands have been reclaimed. Institutions have been rebuilt. New enterprises and movements have emerged. Striving towards meaningful living continues. This reveals something important:

Indigenous Peoples have not just survived the destruction of their worlds. They have continued to create worlds despite it.

That history offers a different perspective on contemporary anxieties about the future. The Māori whakataukī (proverb): “He kai kei aku ringa” (I have food in my hand), reminds us that we make our own futures.

2. The colonisation of the future

Colonisation is usually discussed in relation to land, people, resources, knowledge and institutions. A less discussed dimension is that it was also an attempt to determine Indigenous futures by imposing one group’s vision upon another. Indigenous Peoples were expected to assimilate, abandon their languages and ways of life, adopt externally imposed institutions and participate in economic systems designed by others. Yet no single worldview has a monopoly on imagining desirable futures. This raises a question that remains relevant today:

Who has the authority to imagine the future?

Is anyone else tired of billionaire elites hijacking our ability to dream of flourishing futures? Much contemporary discussion treats the future as something that simply happens to us, shaped by developments beyond our control. Why should any of us accept the dystopian futures imagined by governments, corporations and technology developers as inevitable?

For Indigenous Peoples, self-determination must mean more than the right to participate in existing institutions or adapt to emerging conditions. It must also include the right to imagine, determine and create futures on our own terms. There is an important difference between being included in someone else’s future and having the authority to imagine your own. As the whakataukī says: Ko te pae tawhiti, whāia kia tata. Ko te pae tata, whakamaua kia tina (Seek distant horizons and draw them near, while holding firm to what you hold precious).

From surviving the future to creating it: The role of higher education

Higher education is increasingly focused on preparing students for the future of work, the AI economy and a rapidly changing world. We teach them skills for emerging industries and encourage them to adapt to technological disruption. But whose future are we preparing them for?

If universities simply accept dominant forecasts, they risk becoming institutions that reproduce existing visions of society rather than places where alternative possibilities are developed.

Education should equip students to navigate change. But it should also equip them to question whether the changes being predicted are desirable, whose interests they serve and what alternatives might exist. The purpose of education should not just be to prepare people for the future, but to enable them to help determine it.

Our imagination is constrained by a world we already know

We tend to imagine the future by extending the present. If capitalism dominates contemporary economic life, we imagine future economies as more technologically advanced versions of capitalism. If competition and accumulation define success today, we imagine future societies organised around greater competition and accumulation.

Even our dystopias often preserve the fundamental structures of the present. They simply intensify them. We rarely ask whether the underlying arrangements themselves might be different.

This is what makes Indigenous futurism so intellectually interesting. It allows us to ask different questions about what a future society could be. Indigenous futures need not recreate the past. They can incorporate advanced technologies, new institutions, and entirely different economic arrangements while remaining grounded in Indigenous philosophies and aspirations. Indigenous knowledge is not just a collection of traditions to be preserved, but a living source of ideas from which new possibilities can emerge.

For Indigenous Peoples, this is not an abstract philosophical exercise. It is intimately connected to the continuing struggle for self-determination.

Why, then, should we accept dystopia as the future? The often-quoted words of Māori leader Sir Āpirana Ngata to the next generation capture this perspective:

E tipu, e rea, mō ngā rā o tō ao

ko tō ringa ki ngā rākau a te Pākehā hei oranga mō tō tinana,

ko tō ngākau ki ngā taonga o ō tīpuna hei tikitiki mō tō māhunga,

a ko tō wairua ki tō Atua, nāna nei ngā mea katoa

Grow, tender youth, in these new times,

grasp the tools of technology and innovation,

but hold onto the wisdom and values of your ancestors,

while maintaining reverence for the almighty creator.

The future is not simply something waiting to happen to us. We have the right and the responsibility to imagine the future we want. And the world needs higher education to prepare students to take part in making it.

MEET THE AUTHOR


Dr Kiri Dell is a Senior Lecturer at the University of Auckland Business School and is of Ngāti Porou descent. She lives on her tribal lands in the small community of Ruatōria, where she is engaged with her large and lively whānau (family). Her research explores Māori economies, Indigenous entrepreneurship and how Indigenous knowledge can reshape understandings of value, prosperity and economic development.